As the holiday season approaches, Sarah is looking for ways to make the Christmas season—the first without her beloved father—special, when she comes across directions for a Christmas mystery quilt. She doesn’t know what the finished holiday keepsake will look like because each week a set on instructions will be posted online. Sarah tried to focus on the project, but she notices some odd typos throughout the instructions and begins to suspect that not everything is as it seems. And when a string of thefts plagues the merchants of Maple Hill, she starts investigating and discovers that there’s a pattern to the thefts. Could there be a connection no one else sees? While Sarah finishes her Christmas shopping and prepares for a quiet holiday with her family, she is shocked to find out what’s really going on in town!